ICLR 2027 · Rebuttal tracker
How much did the rebuttal move scores?
Every paper's initial review scores against live OpenReview data.
Look up your initial score
Type your paper's initial scores, in any order. See how papers that started the same way have moved so far.
Try:
By initial mean score
Higher starting scores moved up more often. Papers near the bottom mostly withdrew instead.
Share of papers whose score went up or down
Papers still under review with the same number of reviews as initially. Means with fewer than 100 papers are not shown.
Went upWent downGray labels: mostly 4-review papers
Share of papers withdrawn so far
All papers that had initial scores.
Review by review
Each review's initial rating → now
Counts of reviews. Off-diagonal cells are changes; the diagonal is reviews that kept their rating.
Updates
Each row is one pass over all submissions. The discussion closes on , so expect late moves.
Data
- Initial scores come from the snapshot by shiqiangw, taken right after reviews were released. Current scores come from the OpenReview API.
- Score changes count only papers still under review with the same number of reviews.
- Review-level moves are matched by edit time; are inferred.
- Only counts are published: no review text, reviewer ids or paper titles.